The long awaited decision on what will happen to the Parent Category Visa is still up in the air, but will be made before the end of the current government’s term.
The Immigration Minister Iain Lees Galloway stated that he was still considering the future of the visa and it would be inappropriate to comment on it. He also wouldn’t give a specific time frame on a decision other than to say it would be before the end of this current term of Government. However previous dates have also been given as to when a decision on the Parent Category would be made and these have all come and gone.
These comments came after Immigration New Zealand (INZ) gave a submission to the Education and Workforce select committee confirming there was no evidence that people on the Parent Category Visas were taking advantage of social welfare assistance. INZ stated that the evidence from sponsors here since 2013 found that, from between 2 and 5 years after obtaining residence, only one percent of parents had accessed social welfare benefits.
For a number of years there have been claims from some parties that sponsors were failing in their obligations to support their parents and, in some cases, returning to their home country leaving their parents stranded in New Zealand to fend for themselves, and burdening the country. These claims can now be seen for what they are, unsubstantiated sensationalism. In INZ’s words “The data doesn’t bear out there are large numbers of what I call the stranded”.
The current Parent Category Visa was frozen in October 2016 by the previous National Government whilst they reviewed the policy. This was at a time when there were claims of sponsors abusing the system and neglecting their parental sponsorship obligations. There were also claims that the high cost of health care for aging parents negated the economic benefits from parent migration arising from the care of grandchildren and the freeing up of their parents to work and contribute greater to society. These claims were particularly driven by the NZ First party.
It is apparent the Parent Category Visa is a major point of contention for the coalition Government. The Labour party is clearly in favour of either re-opening the existing category or introducing an amended policy which will at least facilitate some opportunity for parent residence. However the NZ First party opposes parent migration due, we understand, to their contention that the cost outweighs the benefit.
By the Minister stating a decision will be made by the end of this government term (around September 2020) is he really saying, there’s no way they can get this through their coalition partner so they’ll leave it to the end of their term and make it an election campaign promise? This appears to be the only plausible explanation for the ongoing delays and lack of direction or action on the policy.
There is no doubt that the Parent Category Visa is highly regarded by migrants and, as the evidence suggests, it is not being abused, and some type of visas allowing parent migration should exist. If the benefits of family reunification are acknowledged and accepted but concerns exist over social welfare and health demands, then the compromise may be a long term temporary visitor visa. Resident visa holders have greater access to the Health and Social welfare systems and can also work, but visitors do not have this same access. A 5 year visitor visa, for example, with a requirement to hold medical insurance will allow family reunification without the risk of any burden to New Zealand’s health and welfare resources. While this is not the ideal outcome for many families, who clearly desire long term certainty, it may prove to be the only compromise possible with this current Government. Interestingly Australia has recently introduced a similar visa for parents.
In the meantime Expression of Interest applications, the first step of the Parent Category resident visa, are still being taken and the Government is very happy to receive the EOI application fee of $490, this has recently increased from $430. At the time of the last Parent Category EOI draw in August 2016, before the category closed in October 2016, there were still 3540 EOI’s in the pool awaiting selection, and in January 2019 it was reported that a further 1730 EOI’s had been received by INZ since the category closed. This means there are around 5000+ EOIs in the queue (having paid over $2 million in application fees) and if the Government does not re-open the Parent Category then these applicants have a good case to obtain a refund of their EOI fee.
The Parent Retirement Residence Category, requiring an investment of $1 million over 4 years, remains open for those families who can meet this criteria.
For now though the state of limbo for the Parent Category Visa will continue until the current coalition Government can agree or a single party prevails at the next election. We can be confident that the two main parties, Labour and National will campaign strongly on re-opening the Parent Category Visa as they attempt to secure the increasingly important migrant vote.
Always seek professional advice from an experienced licensed immigration adviser